"Collective" and "individual" are not concepts to be pitted in a death struggle against each other. They're a dialectic to be negotiated, by individuals living among each other in groups. As for "communitarian", well, one should only hope. "Communitarian" means that neighbors care enough about each other to help each other out.

If you have individual rights, then so does everybody else. You don't get to do the "rights" thing while disregarding the rights of other people.

I also have to say that, someone hollering about their "God Given rights" falls on my ears sort of strangely. It's suspicious to play that card, like a mugger playing a Murphy game- tackling someone to steal their wallet while claiming to be police making an arrest. Using ALL CAPS doesn't help that impression.