Make money doing the work you believe in

Big E's avatar
Big E
Jan 3
Big E’s Big Mouth Substack

Idaho Politics & Beyond — Child Protective Services: are they helping or harming? Idaho Legislative Session 2026. By Representative Lucas Cayler (01/01/26). Last update 01/09/25

substack.com/inbox/post…

I propose we take logical, appropriate action and put a decisive end to the needless removal of children living in safe homes with loving parents, and devote our CPS resources — however limited they may be — to helping the children who are being abused or neglected and require intervention from the state.

At the end of the day, it cannot be disputed that a child’s best chances of success, stability, and happiness will be achieved if they are raised by loving parents in a safe home. No one will care for more or love a child better than their parents will. — Rep. Lucas Cayler (LD 11B, tinyurl.com/3mjejka6)

Rep. Cayler will be a champion for Child Protective Services reform in 2026. Please follow and support his work and re-election.

Summary (Grok, edited; images from article)

Rep. Cayler questions whether Idaho's Child Protective Services (CPS) helps or harms families. He highlights wrongful child removals, funding incentives, and high foster care abuse rates. He also proposes reforms to improve accountability and protect parental rights.

Main Thesis

CPS interventions during medical visits can lead to child separations, legal battles, and financial ruin for parents. CPS in Idaho harms families through:

  • Wrongful removals based on perceived neglect.

  • Inverts normal due process by presuming guilt.

  • Functions as a funding-driven system.

Rep. Cayler calls for reforms to restore parental rights and focus on genuine abuse.

Living Through Hell - Real Events of Wrongful Separation in Idaho

  • Kristine’s Story: Mother charged with neglect after seeking care for son's influenza; spent $40,000 on legal fees; charges against her dismissed (cases CR14-19-11336, CV01-21-00739).

  • Tragic Tale of Baby Cyrus: Parents lost custody due to underweight concerns from weaning; custody restored. (See details in ED NOTE and Related links below.)

  • Rebecca’s case: Child removed for spinal knot. Hospital claimed surgery was urgent, then delayed it for five months. Ongoing reunification efforts.

  • Bunting’s story: Autistic teen removed after teacher report. Teen was placed in restrictive care for two years until aging out. Now reunited with parents.

CPS Establishment

CPS origins trace to 1974 Child Abuse Protection and Treatment Act (CAPTA, Public Law 93-247), which provided federal funding for child protection and was adopted by all 50 states.

Funding - State and Federal

  • U.S. states: $34.3 billion spent on child welfare in FY2022 via Title IV-E (foster care) and IV-B (family services).

  • Idaho:

    • $61.7 million for Youth Safety and Permanency.

    • $74.6 million for foster care (2025 Senate Bills 1108 and 1208).

    • Total: ~$62,400 per child per year based on 1,195 children in care as of November 18, 2025.

Statistical Data

  • Approximately 3.2% of U.S. children investigated annually.

  • Idaho had over 24,000 referrals and 15,000 investigations in FY2025, with 60% reunification rate (not very good).

  • Idaho Department of Health & Welfare (IDHW, aka CPS) aims to double foster homes by 2026.

  • 40% of foster children report abuse

  • Foster children four times more likely to face sexual abuse; group home children 28 times more likely.

Legal Precedent (or lack thereof) U.S. due process presumes innocence, but CPS allows removals on reports without evidence, for issues including underweight children or parental medical decisions.

ED NOTE 
"Underweight" can be in the eye of the beholder and may not be accurate for any given child. Additionally, weight charts have changed over the decades (see ChatGPT discussion here: tinyurl.com/58z75shu).

In Baby Cyrus case, his father is tall and thin. Cyrus also suffered from cyclical vomiting syndrome (a condition not caused by parents, now mostly under control). These bouts of vomiting led to dehydration and some weight loss, causing his parents to take him to the hospital out of "abundance of caution." Cyrus was otherwise growing normally and deemed healthy by initial hospital evaluation. He became much sicker after continued hospitalization under CPS auspices. In hospital, he was denied access to maternal breast milk and facial burns occurred due to uncleaned vomit.

Proposed Reforms:

  • Social Worker Reform: Training requirements, conduct rules, penalties, mental health screenings, autism-specific training.

  • CPS Registry reform: Due process for listings under 5th and 14th Amendments.

  • Medical Neglect: Clarified definitions, protections against false accusations.

  • Medical Kidnapping: New code section defining and penalizing medical kidnapping; amending kidnapping statute.

Conclusion

  • End needless removals from loving homes to prioritize abused children.

  • Parents generally provide best care.

  • Redirect CPS resources to verified cases.

  • Address staffing and funding by focusing on genuine neglect.

__________

Related:

Jan 3
at
1:11 PM
Relevant people

Log in or sign up

Join the most interesting and insightful discussions.