Although this essay makes many valid points, to be convincing, it would need to consider the distinction between language as expression and language as formula. Recipients of engraved invitations do not assume that they express the printer’s desires. I do not know how truly creative 303 Creation’s wedding announcements are. If they include, for example, original poetry with each wedding webpage they design, then Ms. Smith should be allowed to select her clients for any reason she deems fit. If, however, these webpages are boiler plate, as most wedding invitations are, then to my mind she is refusing to provide a standard product—and no more justified in doing so than a clothing store would be in refusing to provide a gay couple tuxedoes.