See my comment here: caitlinjohnstone.substa…

(You seem to have replied to the wrong comment)

>>"A Jew is a person who practices Judaism. There is no such thing as a Jewish culture"

Are you the authority on this? Why should anyone take your definition over so many better and more widely accepted ones? What grants you the right/superiority on dictating to others "your definition/understanding" as the official one (or even accepted one)?

Why do you keep repeating the same talking points? Why would you believe "Israel's definition of what a Jew/Jewish person is"? As you say - the Zionist state is full of crap - so then why are you looking up to them to tell you stuff?

You haven't answered ANY of my points in the comment I made - not provided evidence/links/resources to back up your statements or theories.

>>"Watch some of Rabbi Yaacov Shapiro's interviews."

I enoy watching his vidoes - and respect his opinion quite a bit. But that doesn't make "his opinion" the de-facto supreme authority to everything about Jews/Jewishness.

I'm beginning to have doubts about your ability for objective analysis...