Greetings from Toronto.

I share your opinion, our leader Caitlin has a strong diagnosis and she’s a pleasure to read but her prescription is nowhere: kevetching plus wishful thinking. She’s a commentator and a bloody good one, honest, but not in the world or a product of the world she sits on the sidelines pontificating.

I find the entire left devoid of solutions, left liberalism has become a cul-de-sac, it is exhausted. I think they know they have failed (as you say) hence their impatience- the successor ideology of Wes Yang - and this illiberal moment.