Thanks very much for that! Although you have now officially shifted the goalposts away from the original point I made--which you well understand is true--you now wish to move onto what you hope is firmer ground. While appreciating your surrender on my original point, the ground you have chosen to move to is... not firm? As in, a foetid, dismal swamp where your fellow travelers/marsh creatures often take the form of MAGAts and Proud Boys. Excellent company, that. Just your speed, really.

Paradoxically, I am both saddened and pleased by your increasing comfort with loudly proclaiming antisemitic shibboleths. I think it's important to realize that, while a principled free speech case can be made for Halper, it also attracts gleefully unprincipled antisemites--you yourself are living proof of this.

King David Hotel bombing? Really? That's what you've got?

Oh, and lest the main point be forgotten--"Palestinian" national Arab identity is of terrifyingly recent vintage. Indeed, after the formation of the state of Israel, there were important Arabs who considered the whole concept of such an identity a Zionist plot.