Granted, I admire Clive Bates and our priors largely align (though far from universally! Ask us about a reduced-nicotine product standard for combusted tobacco products!), but his inaugural ‘stack is perhaps as clear and persuasive an expression of what a “tobacco harm minimizing” world could look like that I’ve encountered.

Please read.

If you disagree with Clive, do you believe your evidence and arguments are stronger than his? If yes, would you please do him the courtesy (and the rest of us the benefit!) of responding in comments?