Several years ago, heck probably more like back in the hey day they had some great formulas. I really liked a few eyeshadow palettes and lip glosses. But I feel like they pulled a bait and switch with quality. I tried something under the new owners and the quality (in my opinion) is not the same. Heck they changed it towards the end of Linda owning it too. I’ve moved on. I’m sticking with my tried and true and not wasting my money anymore. Also they aren’t marketing to me so I don’t think they want my money anyways.