Damn, this is great work Lily. You found some egregious examples of low quality, cheap listicle pages. This is lazy marketing work only exacerbated by AI content creation. Google has no choice but to crack down. The days of self-serving puffery are probably coming to an end soon. I do wonder if a comprehensive listing page done “right” with real research and insights can stand the test of time? So few are doing that unfortunately. It will be interesting to see how things play out here.