The app for independent voices

Hi Geoff.

Open Electricity did not 'say' anything.

But they, very quietly, changed the effect of selecting 'Consumption' or 'Generation' above the table.

So, for example, for Victoria, 7 days @ ½-hour intervals for 25 Jan 2026 10:30pm to 1 Feb 2026 10:30 pm AEST, we now get EITHER:

*** Consumption ***

Sources GWh Contribution to Demand

Solar (Rooftop) 175 13.2%

Solar (Utility) 62 4.7%

Wind 209 15.8%

Hydro 68 5.2%

Battery (Discharging) 13.1 1.0%

Gas (OCGT) 14.1 1.1%

Gas (Steam) 5.0 0.4%

Coal (Brown) 654 49.2% ==> hence Demand = 1,329.3 GWh

Imports 21.6 1.6%

[Sum 92.2% of these OpenElec %s]

Loads

Exports 106 8.0%

Battery (Charging) 17.9 1.3%

Curtailment

Solar (Utility) 27.3 2.1%

Wind 47 3.6%

Net 1,346

Renewables 516 46.1% [OpenElec claimed]

actually 516/1,329.3 = 38.8% [consistent with Coal (brown) Demand]

~~~~~~~~~~~~ OR ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

*** Generation ***

Sources GWh Contribution to Generation

Solar (Rooftop) 175 14.6%

Solar (Utility) 62 5.2%

Wind 210 17.5%

Hydro 68 5.7%

Battery (Discharging) 13.1 1.1%

Gas (OCGT) 14.1 1.2%

Gas (Steam) 5.0 0.4%

Coal (Brown) 654 54.4% ==> hence Generation = 1,202.2 GWh

Imports 21.7 **

[Sum 112.1% + imports % would be 21.7/1,202.2 = 1.8% ==>

a total of ??? 113.9% Generation ???]

Exports 106 **

Battery (Charging) 17.9 **

** [no % stated by OpenElec]

Curtailment

Solar (Utility) 27.3 2.3%

Wind 47 4.0%

Net 1,346

Renewables 516 42.9% [OpenElec claimed]

actually 516/1,202.2 = 42.9% [consistent with Coal (brown) Generation]

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

So Open Electricity have changed how the interface presents the summary data, and now if you select *** Generation *** [the default is Consumption, so you have to select the non-default] the % 'renewables' presented is consistent with the Generation value that can be derived from the dominant source = Coal (Brown) 654GWh 54.4% ... but that 54.4% is consistent with a total of 113.9% of contributions of sources of Generation...

Which is NOT balanced by the total of Loads:

106 export + 17.9 battery charging = 123.9 GWh / 1,202.2 = 10.3%

So that leaves an imbalance of about ??? 3.6% ??? of Generation

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

So neither option makes consistent sense.

Great. Let me know if/what they say!

Feb 1
at
1:39 PM
Relevant people

Log in or sign up

Join the most interesting and insightful discussions.