The app for independent voices

The Bobington Daily News's avatar

Check out my new post!

The Disgusting Rituals Known as Brushing and Nail Clipping
Friend's avatar

Best advice I received:

If you overthink, Write.

If you underthink, Read.

and that is all.

Aziza Lynn-The Bargain Beauty's avatar

I just released my Sephoria Newsletter yesterday, and this is what I wake up to this morning.

I’m #48 and rising in the Fashion & Beauty space!

I am overwhelmed with all the love and support from each and every one of you! You have no idea how full my heart is!! I can’t wait to give my subscribers the experience of a lifetime!

THANK YOU!!!

Aziza-Lynn

You made it, you own it

You always own your intellectual property, mailing list, and subscriber payments. With full editorial control and no gatekeepers, you can do the work you most believe in.

CTL Tribune's avatar
Fights break out at Hamden High
Eileen Tremaine's avatar

Great discussions

Join the most interesting and insightful discussions.

Thee Book Club's avatar
Jasmine Crockett's avatar

We live in a time that people are more inclined to obey an unlawful executive order than they are to follow a court order 🤦🏾‍♀️.

Dictators are created due to cruelty, cowardice, & compliance! IF THEIR ASSES will ignore the Supreme Court, we can definitely IGNORE HIM!

Grow your publication on Substack

With recommendations, referrals, and a powerful growth network, Substack creators spend less time on marketing and more time on their craft.

hasif 💌's avatar

sometimes i wonder how many versions of myself i’ve outgrown without even noticing. i look back at old photos and remember the thoughts i used to carry, the dreams i thought would save me. it’s strange how you can live inside yourself every day and still not realize you’re evolving. it’s only when you look back that you realize how far you’ve come, how many lives you’ve already lived in the same skin.

Practical Stoic Advice's avatar

My father always told me:

"If you want to go for a run, go for a run, don't look for company.

Sooner or later, on your fifth run or your twentieth, like-minded people will find you themselves."

And only recently have I realised that this principle works everywhere.

You made it, you own it

You always own your intellectual property, mailing list, and subscriber payments. With full editorial control and no gatekeepers, you can do the work you most believe in.

Pakachoag Music School's avatar
The most difficult note is the first one.
Scott DeGroff's avatar

World-class writing

The best stories, ideas, and culture right at your fingertips.

Diane Lee's avatar

YES !!! 💪💯🎯

It’s about damn time. AOC is a hero. She’s one of the best out there, fighting daily against Trump’s fascist bullshit.

Gigi Nadeau's avatar

anyone else?

Grow your publication on Substack

With recommendations, referrals, and a powerful growth network, Substack creators spend less time on marketing and more time on their craft.

StreamScoop's avatar

Sports on TV tonight:

• WWE NXT on the CW

• IND-CLE & DEN-OKC G5's on TNT, truTV & Max

• The WPG-DAL G4 on ESPN

Sports Streaming Guide: NBA and NHL Semifinals, WNBA Regular Season start, free MLB games and more!
Friend's avatar

Go on more walks. Walk for no reason. Walk to solve a problem. Walk to blow off steam. Walk to get outside. Walk to listen, read, and learn. Walk to escape distractions. Walk to improve your health. Walk to think. A simple walking habit can change absolutely everything.

Grow Your Audience

Marketing isn’t all on your shoulders. More than 50% of all new free subscriptions and 25% of paid subscriptions come from within our network.

Scott Leeth's avatar
Portsmouth LGBTQ+ Resolution Fails
Adam Kinzinger's avatar

Just FYI because evidently Fox or OAN or whatever is pushing the lie that America accepted the Statue of Liberty and that’s equivalent to the plane.

Congress VOTED to approve receiving the statue. So congress should vote on the jet

You made it, you own it

You always own your intellectual property, mailing list, and subscriber payments. With full editorial control and no gatekeepers, you can do the work you most believe in.

AA<3's avatar

every time I open Substack i feel like I’m a part of dead poets society

JD Flynn's avatar
Cardinal Mahony's autograph, the kirchensteuer, and a midwest dive bar
Quadratus's avatar

I am uncertain why the West, especially The Pillar don't comprehend the difference between the UOC and the OCU. 1. The UOC recently severed all relations with Moscow; yet, your article states otherwise. 2. The UOC is apostolic and canonical; it always has been; and it's recognized as such by all of the local Orthodox churches as such. 3. The OCU is a false church neither possessing apostolicity--no apostolic ordinations--and is the creation of the US Government (USG) and the Ecumenical Patriarc…

Father Adam McMillan's avatar

The pope literally already did that. It is called the Anglican Ordinariates. Many Catholics are pretty happy about it.

Your definition of apostolic sounds like it is different from the Catholic one. I would appreciate understanding the definition of apostolic that you are using. I think it would help us understand the difference in the way of thinking. For us, an apostolic ordination is any ordination by a true bishop. What else is required for your definition?

Quadratus's avatar

Apostolic ordination, in Orthodoxy, is the same as in Catholicism--ordination by an apostolically ordained bishop from a canonical local Orthodox church. I would commend to you, that in the West, the Anglican Ordinariates are not in the same category as the non-apostolic, non-canonical OCU who refuse to be ordained by an apostolic bishop, i.e., meaning no corrective measures to validate the OCU priesthood will be accepted. It's akin to a Calvinist Baptist without having attended a seminary bein…

Father Adam McMillan's avatar

It sounds like the difference is "from a canonical local Orthodox church." We wouldn't have that stipulation.

So if a UOC bishop goes to Iraq and ordains a man, you would say that the ordination is not valid?

For Catholics the local part does not matter. Surely the OCU bishops were ordained by some bishop? But you are saying that the problem is that he was not from the UOC? So would you also say that the Ukrainian Catholic bishops are not apostolic?

Quadratus's avatar

If a UOC bishop were to seek to ordain someone in Iraq, first the UOC bishop would need permission from the local Iraqi Orthodox bishop, and, second, the person to be ordained would (likely) only be permitted to serve Ukrainians. The exception would be that the Iraqi Orthodox bishop is petitioned by the layman to have the UOC bishop perform the ordination based on a prior relationship between the two (the UOC bishop and the layman). A bishop cannot travel into another local bishop's *territory…

So, yes, that is the difference. Catholics would say that a bishop cannot lose his apostolic ordination nor lose his ability to ordain apostolic bishops. For instance, when Archbishop Lefebvre ordained four bishops, they are apostolic and validly ordained despite him not having permission to do so. This is why we recognize all the Orthodox and Old Catholics and Polish National Catholics etc as having apostolic orders despite the canonical disputes. So long as the form and matter are correct, a bishop validly ordains. Being defrocked by Moscow does not, according to our theology, have any effect upon his apostolicity.

The main reason for the Catholics to be in dialogue with any Christians is to achieve what Jesus called for, "That they may be one as we are one."

6 Likes
1 Reply
Aug 2, 2022
at
7:21 PM
Quadratus's avatar

"Being defrocked by Moscow does not, according to our theology, have any effect upon his apostolicity." Interesting, so if the Pope were to defrock, anathematize, and laicize a bishop, that same *former bishop* could still ordain a priest? Yes, Orthodoxy is very different. As a priest, I cannot perform the Holy Mysteries in another local Orthodox church without first getting permission from my bishop and then receiving permission from the bishop whose church I am going to visit.

Father Adam McMillan's avatar

Absolutely! If Mr. Theodore McCarick were to ordain his cellmate a bishop, that man would be a bishop. Sacramental authority and Canonical authority have some overlap in Catholic theology but not completely.

I do have to ask for permission to celebrate Mass in another diocese, but if I fail to get the permission, the Mass would still be valid, the bread and wine would still change.

JD Flynn's avatar

And the Catholic Church would also hold that a validly ordained Orthodox bishop - even if he were laicized, excommunicated, censured, etc by his patriarch or synod - could continue to perform valid ordinations or consecrations.

Quadratus's avatar

I think I understand. He could validly ordain a priest, but it would be against the law and so be illicit. Valid because Jesus shows up, illicit because He would not be pleased.

Quadratus's avatar

I don't want to make Jesus mad.