The Premiers meeting this week was a real eye-opener, showing just how tricky it can be to balance provincial and federal interests. And right in the thick of it is Alberta’s Premier, Danielle Smith, who’s found herself in a bit of an awkward spot. Why, you ask? Well, aside from her odd chumminess with Donald Trump—seriously, a weekend jaunt to Mar-a-Lago and plans to attend his inauguration?—she’s been steering Alberta in a direction that’s causing some raised eyebrows.

Smith's focus on protecting Alberta’s oil industry makes sense given its importance to the province’s economy. But here’s the rub: oil is a hot-button issue, especially as we push towards green energy. Meanwhile, Canada’s trying to juggle putting a price on carbon while still propping up the fossil fuel industry. It’s a bit of a head-scratcher, really—oil revenues are crucial not just for Alberta, but for the federal government too, providing jobs and fuelling budgets.

Then there’s Trump’s looming 25% tariffs, which could seriously mess with the Canadian economy. Right now, it’s all about playing the waiting game to see if these tariffs will hit us across the board, or if, fingers crossed, oil might get a pass given the U.S.'s reliance on it.

Now, here’s where it gets even more tangled. Ontario’s Premier, Doug Ford, is rallying for a united front against these tariffs, saying we should protect our own turf but always put Canada first. It's a solid point, given that oil is our ace in the hole—a big bargaining chip in the face of Trump’s wild tariff plans. But Smith’s solo approach could undermine this strategy.

The way I see it, Alberta needs to think about joining forces with the other provinces. A united stance gives us a stronger hand to play on the world stage, ensuring we protect both provincial and national interests. By weaving Alberta's oil concerns into a broader Canadian strategy, we can amplify our voice globally and maybe, just maybe, take some wind out of Trump’s tariff sails.

So, what’s next? It’s a delicate dance, this one. But one thing’s for sure: how Alberta chooses to move forward could tip the balance for all of Canada. Let’s hope they choose wisely. Things can get very ugly, indeed.

I tossed a question out to my social media followers, asking for their take on Ontario Premier Doug Ford's advice to Alberta Premier Danielle Smith regarding the Trump tariffs: “...protect your jurisdiction but country comes first, Canada’s the priority.” The overwhelming sentiment leaned in favour of Ford, yet the responses shed light on a deeper divide. Many pointed out that Alberta has often found itself at odds with the rest of Canada, citing examples like stalled pipeline expansions and the Keystone XL debacle. Some argue Smith was elected to defend Alberta's interests, especially when those interests seem sidelined by national strategies. Others highlighted Alberta’s role as a major contributor to federal transfer payments, questioning why it should shoulder the burden without due consideration. A sentiment echoed was Alberta feeling like the 51st state, as its interests are perceived to be overridden by Ontario’s convenience. Meanwhile, some viewed Ford's comment as perhaps his smartest yet, though motives were questioned—is it genuine, or just a strategic move for votes? The debate underscores the complex dynamics of provincial versus national priorities in Canada, and how this tension plays into the broader tariff negotiations.

Enjoy the January 17, 2025 making-of animated editorial cartoon below. Please subscribe to my Substack newsletter, if you haven’t already. Posts come out every Friday or Saturday as I summarize the week that was in my editorial cartoons. What you’re reading now is regarded as a “note”, which is used to help compose my weekly posts and showcase the animated versions of my daily editorial cartoons.