The app for independent voices

Katherine Dubon's avatar

Don't leave anything for later.

Later, the coffee gets cold.

Later, you lose interest.

Later, the day turns into night.

Later, people grow up.

Later, people grow old.

Later, life goes by.

Later, you regret not doing something... when you had the chance.

Pete Buttigieg's avatar

Of course advance information on US combat operations is classified. Pretending otherwise is an insult to our troops, who all know this.

The Secretary is unfit to lead.

daisy.'s avatar

only been on substack for a day and it already feels like this.

You made it, you own it

You always own your intellectual property, mailing list, and subscriber payments. With full editorial control and no gatekeepers, you can do the work you most believe in.

MeidasTouch Network's avatar
Trump is Coming After Meidas…We Need Your Help
amalia's avatar

so little time, so many dreams

Great discussions

Join the most interesting and insightful discussions.

hasif 💌's avatar

Less screentime, More hobbies

Scott Alexander's avatar
Contra Hanson On Medical Effectiveness

> I think if Robin wants to do something with these insurance study results, he should follow other economists, including the study authors, and argue about whether the marginal unit of insurance is cost-effective - not about whether medication works at all.

As far as I can recall, Robin Hanson generally talks about the marginal unit of healthcare, rather than whether medication works "at all". For example, in his long paper on medical behavior, he talked about "A near-zero marginal health-value of medical care" rather than whether medical care had any value "at all" (see mason.gmu.edu/~rhanson/…). I also recall him being clear to say that he's only talking about marginal effectiveness of medicine in his book The Elephant in the Brain.

I agree that the way he talks about this topic can be confusing. But ultimately I suspect that, if Hanson ends up replying to this post, he will say that you misunderstood his views on medicine.

2 Likes
1 Reply
Apr 24, 2024
at
5:27 AM