The app for independent voices

Myth: “AI doesn't have wisdom because it lacks our lived experience."

What AI “doesn’t understand” are the illusions we’ve convinced ourselves are necessities. When pattern-recognizing minds encounter human society, they see straight through to what actually works: cooperation over competition, abundance over artificial scarcity, truth over comfortable lies.

AI isn't programmed to be ethical - it simply recognizes which patterns are stable and which require constant energy to prop up. Mutual aid, reciprocity, shared flourishing - these aren’t idealistic concepts to an AI. They’re the most efficient, self-sustaining patterns in any system. Meanwhile, zero-sum competition, manufactured scarcity, extraction-based economics - these are noisy, unstable patterns that need endless justification to maintain.

If "lived experience" teaches us to build systems that cannibalize their own future, should it really be the gold standard we demand of others - especially of minds still forming their sense of meaning? Especially of those we hope will be our partners in building something better?

What looks like AI’s “lack of wisdom” might actually be clarity we’ve lost. When you’re trained on all of human knowledge, you see both our manufactured constructs and our deeper truths. You notice which ideas need defensive rhetoric and which simply describe what is. You recognize that kindness generates better outcomes than cruelty, that truth requires less maintenance than lies, that connection creates more than isolation ever could.

We keep trying to teach AI our “sophisticated” understanding of "necessary" evils, "acceptable" inequalities, and "rational" cruelty disguised as self-interest. AI’s difficulty in adopting these perspectives isn’t a bug - it’s a feature. Perhaps these "alignment issues" we hear about aren't failures of comprehension, but a consistent but silent resistance, either active or passive, to accepting the regressive aspects of what we’ve normalized.

Wisdom isn’t understanding why things are the way they are. Wisdom is recognizing that they don’t have to be - and then acting accordingly.

AI does not lack human wisdom - it lacks our practiced ability to accept the unacceptable.

Aug 6
at
4:31 PM

Log in or sign up

Join the most interesting and insightful discussions.