Great question, but I would say any movie I keep returning to is definitely one of my favorites. Almost all of mine are from 2010 or before.
Here’s a list of (some of) my most watched films in alphabetical order:
Alien
Aliens
The Bourne Identity trilogy
Casino Royale (Daniel Craig, not David Niven)
Dark City
The Dark Knight
Die Hard
Fight Club
The Gentlemen (recent addition)
The Godfather I & II
Goodfellas
John Wick (the original)
The Matrix (first one only)
Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
The Princess Bride
The Rock
The Sting
Terminator 2
The Thing (John Carpenter)
Movie Questions of the Week: What movie have you seen the most times in your life? Not your "favorite." Just the one you keep returning to.