172 Comments

You are courageous man, a great speaker and a gifted writer. Thank you for this text and your fight for truth and peace.

Expand full comment

The Jews in Israel are really demonstrating their infinite bloodlust in Gaza!

Always remember, the story of this family and little girl, all killed by the IDF, is only ONE of thousands of such stories... and the world just watches in disgust...unable to stop the worst war crimes and massacre in the modern world today.

Never forget, for there must be justice for these victims.

Expand full comment

How I ironic is it that all these Biblical passages that Bibi Nuttyahoo talks about were written by the ancestors of the very people he is wiping out, all the while, his Genetics are not Middle Eastern, but are Khazarian. There is a reason why DNA testing in Israel can only be allowed via a court order.

Expand full comment

Dear Scott

What is currently happening in Gaza is absolutely terrifying and I am, like many others, in complete shock. Why is nobody helping the Palestinians from dying?

It is high time to take very tough measures against the Apartheid State of Israel and move to very firm and resolute actions as nobody is seriously doing anything.

In my opinion, the ultimate solution to the conflict can only come from the region and it is the responsibility of the Arab League and Iran with Turkey to act united because the Palestinian people cannot count on real aid from the United States, its European allies and even the UN whatsoever. These “Western” states will always and always bend to Israel no matter what. The Zionist lobby is too powerful.

It is therefore imperative that Arab States unite, act and speak together with one common voice:

- condemn the genocide

- call for an immediate ceasefire

- withdraw all their diplomats from Israel

- expel all Israeli diplomats from Arab countries (later also all Israelis)

- boycott all products from Israel and put an end to all forms of trade, aid and relations with Israel

- demand a sovereign and independent Palestinian state which will be built with the help and money of the Arab States – no need to ask for money and be dependent on aid from “Western” countries

- demand that the UN remove the permanent seats of the “5 nations” and their right of veto on any resolution. All nations are equal – no more privileges.

Once this is accomplished, Israel will feel strongly isolated in the region and this is what they fear the most among a very strong and united opposition from the Arab nations (you will just have to look at the map of the Middle East to realize this). The main reason they instigated all these wars in the Middle East over the past few decades with the complicity of the US and its allies was indeed to weaken each Arab state...

These and other measures could force Israel to withdraw from Gaza and peacefully end the ongoing genocide and apartheid state of Israel.

The Arab League must solidify itself as a block of strength in the future – if ever one of its members is attacked a common and immediate response will follow.

To achieve this, people with real human hearts, expertise and knowledge of the Middle East have to come together and intervene politically for the cause of the Palestinian people. These must be respected figures who act as a counterpart to Anthony Blinken, who constantly meets the heads of Arab states and actually only defends Israel and its interests. In the name of humanity courageous people like you, George Galloway and/or others must go and meet and convince the heads of Arab states who are still reluctant. (otherwise nobody will do it…) ALL possible efforts have to be concentrated on that task. The best would be if Palestinian politicians and/or representatives could join to form a very strong delegation.

Even if the chances of success are little, every possible effort has to be conducted with perseverance to persuade these governments that are still reserved (I am sure the local population and people are in favor and supportive)

And even if at first, not everyone is receptive, I am convinced that in the medium to long term they will join the right cause.

The final solution, in my opinion, will only pass through there.

Donors who have good financial means and who are for the Palestinian cause should be contacted to finance this delegation of hope.

You know by far the subject much better than me, what do you think?

I would be happy to assist.

With much respect to you.

Best regards

Olivier

Expand full comment

Thank you for a passionate, testament to the horror unfolding in the Middle East. It is hell on earth we see before us and even more horrific to recognize the base geocidal animosity and greed that underlies this slaughter. The greed shines through in the talk of Gaza spoils; off shore fuels, the new gas pipeline, the highspeed rail and canal to rival Suez. As well as the already underway land seizures in other areas, from the river to the sea.

The world is standing by as an entire population is sacrificed on this altar to Satan. All the while the world's greedy forces smile and support Israel. All together they wash their hands and faces in blood dreaming of the treasure to come.

Expand full comment

Scott, I think you must mean Samarians, and not Samaritans, who did not exist for another 200 years after Samuel and Eli in the Bible timeline. Samaria was the capital of the northern state of Israel when David was fooling around down in Judah and eventually established a kingdom there.

But surely you must be aware that much of what we read in the Hebrew Bible is purely legendary and not historical. There was no Abraham or Moses or Exodus. Modern Jews have purely Canaanite ancient DNA, just like the Palestinians. They have no ancestors in Mesopotamia. There is absolutely no archaeological evidence for any Israelites ever escaping from Egypt (and the Egyptians kept very good records). At the very time when the Exodus was supposed be occurring, Egypt ruled Canaan, so they would have been escaping from one part of the Egyptian Empire to another. At the time when Joshua was supposed to be destroying Jericho and any number of other Canaanite cities, the cities didn't have walls or didn't exist. And there were no "Israelites" at the time either.

There were no Israelites at all until the beginning of the Iron Age, maybe 1200 BC, and then the best guess is that they were a disparate group of people who gathered in the hill country of Canaan, a mixture of former indentured farmers, craftsmen and pastoralists who escaped to that location after the collapse of civilization at the end of the Bronze Age. Suddenly all the land was not owned by a king from somewhere, and people could have some self-determination. Those people developed a communitarian society that was relatively classless at first, based on villages and small towns. They worshipped all the normal Canaanite gods--El, Asherah, Baal, etc. Over the next couple of hundred years those people developed their own identity and began to distinguish themselves from the Philistines who had settled along the coast and formed city states: they developed their own dietary rules (no pigs), and their own unique god, who started out as a minor god of metallurgy. They still worshipped all the other gods, but the priests of Yahweh gained in power and political influence until they began to persecute the worshippers of the other deities, and began to ascribe to Yahweh the "powers" that the other gods had had.

The trouble was, Yahweh was a rather psychopathic mirror image of the culture that invented him. He told people not to murder or steal, but shortly afterward told them to murder every man, woman and child not in their clan, along with all their domestic animals. (This is why the later Talmud tries to make sense of it all by saying the commandments are just for Jews interacting with each other--it is perfectly okay for a Jew to steal from a gentile, or murder one.) Commands from Yahweh to kill their neighbors come thick and fast all through the Hebrew Bible--it is not just through the books of Samuel and Kings that we get such edicts. Note that Judges has one story like that after another as well.

So what the Israelis are doing right now is perfectly in keeping with the culture from which those Bible books sprang. The Zionists who formed the state of Israel founded the state on terrorism. For decades starting in the 1920s they bombed every train, police station, bank, post office, school, orphanage, hotel and movie theatre. They shot every policeman, fireman, elected official, Palestinian and random stranger. They bombed the houses of other Jews who were not sufficiently in tune with their murderous savagery. They recruited 12 and 13 year olds to carry out bombing missions. And the heads of those Zionist terror gangs then became the presidents and prime ministers of Israel, where they went right on terrorizing and murdering people, except now they also assassinated public officials abroad as well.

What Israel is doing right now is what Zionists have always done ever since the first one set foot in Palestine. The Zionist ideology is founded on exceptionalism and racial purity, just as Nazism was, because both beliefs arose from 19th c. German nationalism. The 19th c. Zionists made no secret of this--they were quite open about it in their letters and articles.

Expand full comment

As a devout believer in the “so called god person” I was moved by your analysis. I found it so beautifully written. I suspect that you are more faithful than you let on. I do not believe that religion is the problem but rather the exploitation of the texts to one’s own advantage that desecrates everything that is sacred. I did not listen to The Rolling Stones in the eighties but I will definitely look up the song that inspired you.

Expand full comment

Thank you for writing this, Scott. I cried through most of it.

Expand full comment

What century am I living in?

Expand full comment

If not stopped Israel will start a war pulling the west in killing all the best gentiles. All part of their plans. Do our western young men want to sacrifice themselves for these evil bustards.

Expand full comment

Striking piece, well written.

Expand full comment

People who base their decisions and actions on religious fairy tales are not very wise, but very dangerous. It would be just as reasonable to take the Tales of the Thousand and One Nights for granted, and pick from there, for example, Sinbad as your own household god. In any case, Netanyahu is even sicker than he looks.

Expand full comment

Powerful piece, Scott.

Fearless.

Zionist and their defenders have eviscerated the lives of scores (hundreds, thousands?) of people who dared to question the treatment of the Palestinians, never mind call the whole project of Israel evil.

Zionists, there sycophants, and EVERYBODY in the U.S. Congress know you’re on the moral high ground when you have to censor and destroy those who disagree with you because they’re anti-semites. That’s the ONLY reason someone would oppose Israel. Because it’s “self-defense” to kill women and children…obviously.

Expand full comment
founding
Apr 9·edited Apr 9

THANK YOU !!

It is no longer possible not to call the current state of Israel — a NAZI state.

Hence, Nazi Israel must be destroyed.

Just as the Nazi-dominated government of Ukraine will soon be !

Expand full comment

Thank you for this. I think you are about the only commentator from the North Atlantic Block nations who spells it out this clearly. I appreciate it, because my own feelings and assessment of what the Zionist Occupiers are doing are exactly matched. It's been so disappointing, to find others one had once had respect for saying "I support Israels right to exist".

Expand full comment