New standards of transgender health care raise eyebrows
Controversial recommendations on everything from transition to castration
As if more drama were needed in the gender wars, the public launch of the latest standards of care by the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (wpath) on September 15th was a mess. Known as soc8, they originally included a list of minimum ages for treatments—14 for cross-sex hormones, 15 for removal of breasts, 17 for testicles. Hours later, a “correction” eliminated the age limits. The head of the drafting committee, Eli Coleman, said the publisher went ahead “without approval” before final changes were made.
This only intensified concerns about the document’s “gender-affirming” approach that supports self-diagnosis by adolescents and children. wpath, based in Illinois, has been the main transgender-health organisation that is looked to for guidance across the world. Since its views count, critics worry about soc8 saying hormones and surgery should be allowed at even younger ages. They think this medicalises too many teens who need neither, just therapy. soc8 also says puberty blockers are reversible, a contested claim.
This article appeared in the United States section of the print edition under the headline "Trans plans"
United States September 24th 2022
- Joe Biden warns of global disorder if Russia is not stopped
- Republicans’ abortion proposal could backfire
- Donald Trump faces a sweeping new lawsuit
- Maine’s lobster industry is feeling the pinch
- New standards of transgender health care raise eyebrows
- Detroit is once again betting on the car industry to rescue it
- There is plenty of good news about American government
More from United States
American pupils have missed too much school since the pandemic
But clever policies have got some truant children back in the classroom
Will unions sweep the American South?
The UAW won big at Volkswagen in Tennessee, but organising at other car plants is harder
Why the Republicans will convene in a forge of American socialism
Donald Trump has made gains with Wisconsin’s working class, but Joe Biden could still win there