Home
>
Topics
>
Cookie Recipes

Top 25 cookie recipes on Substack

Best Cookie Recipes


A Cozy Bowl of Chili (and a Box of Girl Scout Cookies)...here's to the weekend

Comforting chili recipes, cozy sides, and a little cookie joy
Hi Friend,
2 LIKES
Kim H.'s avatar
Kim H.
I'm soooooooooo over winter!! But I'm going to order those girl scout cookies TODAY!
Neural Foundry's avatar
Neural Foundry
The chili-as-both-freezer-meal-and-quick-dinner thing is genius for chaotic weeks. I keep forgetting it works both ways until schedules go sideways and I need somthing fast. The flexibility is the real win when everything else feels unpredictable. Also those leftover chili taco dogs sound incredible, definitly trying that next time.

Fwd: from a friend
December 18, 2025

Holiday baking, but make it slightly unhinged

The unglamorous truth behind my cookie boxes (and the 9 recipes I’d actually recommend)
It was on Christmas Eve, three years ago, in the middle of making my Yule Log, a notoriously high-maintenance dessert, that I realized I should probably be medicated.
Emily Schuman ∙ 145 LIKES ∙ 2 RESTACKS
Sudeshna Dillard's avatar
Sudeshna Dillard
It’s a work of art, Emily. You’re an artist. And yes, I agree with some comments here that say it’s incredibly glamorous! You’re a badass! 😊
Alison Schramm's avatar
Alison Schramm
I bake cookies this time of year also and give little bags out to everyone from mail person to waste management to speech therapists. Mine aren’t the prettiest 😂 (following recipes and rules isn’t always my jam!) but there’s something so sweet about giving homemade cookies. “Here, I made this for you” ❤️ It’s also a beautiful connection to my (Italian-American) grandma who made 18 different types of cookies every year with her sisters. Happy holidays!

easygayoven
December 19, 2025

The 7 Recipes in This Year's Cookie Box

A 2025 Cookie Box Recap
This year’s cookie box bonanza wrapped on Wednesday evening and since then, we’ve been in distribution mode. You might think spending almost three days of your life on seven different cookie recipes to fill 17 cookie boxes is the hardest part about this holiday tradition. It’s not. The hardest part is hand-delivering to and coordinating pick-ups with th…
Eric King ∙ 53 LIKES
Patty Terhune's avatar
Patty Terhune
Hahahaha I laughed out loud at the intro. The hamster wheel rarely stops. Happy closure season, EGO! 🍪
Abena Anim-Somuah's avatar
Abena Anim-Somuah
SO FIRE!!!!

Shortcut Baking at Its Best: Cake Mix Cookies

When you want homemade cookies without the extra steps.
Click the ❤️ or 🔄 if you’re enjoying this! It helps more people discover the newsletter and spreads the love. Thanks for reading! 💌
Lois Christensen ∙ 6 LIKES
Michelle Ayers's avatar
Michelle Ayers
Wow! Those cookies look really good!

ZoëBakes Newsletter
December 11, 2025

Cookie Swap Prep: A Few Favorite Recipes

Some of my favorite holiday cookie recipes.
It’s peak holiday cookie season! Today’s a little warmup for my Holiday Cookie Exchange Extravaganza newsletter for “Extras” subscribers. (It’s coming Saturday so upgrade your subscription now to get it in your inbox!)
Zoë François ∙ 37 LIKES ∙ 2 RESTACKS
CHRISTINE PAULL's avatar
CHRISTINE PAULL
Thank you for the recipes, Zoe!
Stephanie Hansen's avatar
Stephanie Hansen
The cookies in @foodandwine spectacular

Justine Doiron’s Chocolate Chip Cookie Quest

Justine Doiron gets deep in the dough on today's episode of our baking podcast
Obsessive Chocolate Chip Cookie Behavior
She's My Cherry Pie ∙ 14 LIKES
RJ's avatar
RJ
This is an interesting conversation for me as a person with celiac disease, as converting standard recipes like Toll House cookies to gluten free cookies always seems to result in something “less than”. Part of the reason is there is no direct replacement for the gluten effect on texture. But, this idea of making ratio charts might be helpful. We have multiple gluten free flours, and they all have different hydration and texture properties, which might also play differently in different product uses (cookies vs cakes vs breads). Thank you for this idea.
Sandra Manley-Eichler's avatar
Sandra Manley-Eichler
I am always so delighted by Justine and her messaging of balance (and honesty about her struggles)! We are also an egg allergy household and we just tried her sour cream cookies- and may never go back! 💛

before I hit publish

everything that happens before a recipe hits your inbox
hey hi hello,
Kassie Mendieta ∙ 36 LIKES
Vee's avatar
Vee
The method behind the madness revealed! 🙌
gabrianna's avatar
gabrianna
If you ever need someone to cross-test a recipe, I’d be down to volunteer 👀

My Favourite Chocolate Chip Cookies

Soft, chewy centres with lightly crisp edges.
These are my go to chocolate chip cookies. They are soft and chewy in the middle, lightly crisp around the edges, and packed with chocolate in every bite. Not too thick, not too thin, and not overly sweet.
Marsha Cook ∙ 2 RESTACKS

Irish Soda Bread Muffin Scones with Raspberry Jam & Brown Cheese

A repost from Food52
My goal for 2026 is to become better at planning out my recipes, which means developing them a month or so in advance, giving myself and my (new) recipe tester ample time to brainstorm and test. However, to do that while still posting content and recipes, I have to slot in pre-existing recipes!
Nea Arentzen ∙ 22 LIKES ∙ 2 RESTACKS
P Sol's avatar
P Sol
Thanks for the recipe! How long would these keep for at room temp and can they be frozen?
Jenna's avatar
Jenna
Hi! I can’t find the recipe…sorry new to substack! Do I find it through Food52 or is it on here? Thanks!!


Lemon Pistachio Almond Shortbread

A cozy little biscuit that also happens to be gluten-free. Not even on purpose. Just because it tastes good.
(Clicking the like button above will mean confectioner’s sugar will fall from the sky over New Jersey instead of snow. It also will help the algorithm and my pursuit of greatness and world cookie domination. [evil laugh] Thank you.)
Marissa Rothkopf ∙ 281 LIKES ∙ 35 RESTACKS
j dinerman's avatar
j dinerman
You mention a “link at the bottom” if you want to help. I couldn’t find it, and I’m always eager to share what you have to say.
I appreciate your recipes and comments. Always. -had
Susan B's avatar
Susan B
Thanks for this yummy looking recipe. Your cookie book is amazing and I gifted a couple too!

The Cookie I’ve Made More Times Than I Can Count

GIANT Single-Serve Chocolate Chip Cookie
When I tell you I actually can’t count how many times I’ve made this GIANT Single-Serve Chocolate Chip Cookie… It’s the perfect dessert when you’re craving something sweet but don’t want to make a whole batch of cookies or spend a lot of time and effort in the kitchen. It’s perfectly gooey on the inside and melts in your mouth, I can’t wait for you to try it!!
Grace Wagner Spradlin ∙ 9 LIKES
Megan Cote's avatar
Megan Cote
My husband and I are in love with these cookies! I have missed cookies so much being gluten free and these are insanely good! Thank you!!
Neural Foundry's avatar
Neural Foundry
Absolutely brillant take on the single-serve concept! The deliberate choice to stay gooey in the middle while maintaining structure is harder than it seems. I've tried almond butter/maple combos before but the ratio here feels differnet than most recips. One thing that really worked for me was adding the flaxseed as actual bindng insurance not just fiber.

17 Minute Small Batch Chocolate Chip Cookies🍪

for 9 perfect chewy cookies!
If you’ve been craving chocolate chip cookies but don’t want to make a whole big batch - I’ve got you covered!
3 LIKES ∙ 1 RESTACKS
Neural Foundry's avatar
Neural Foundry
The "small batch" approach to baking addresses a real problem that doesn't get talked about enough—the economics of home baking often assume you want dozens of cookies, which creates a weird tension between craving and waste. Seventeen minutes start-to-finish with no chill time is genuinely useful information for spontaneous baking.
What's interesting about eliminating the chill step is that it changes the cookie's structural development. Traditional recipes rely on cold dough to slow spread during baking, which creates those crispy edges and chewy centers. When you skip chilling, you're essentially betting that your ratio of fat to flour and your oven temperature can achieve similar results through different mechanics—usually a slightly higher proportion of flour or a hotter initial oven temperature.
The fact that this works for you in 17 minutes suggests you've dialed in that balance. The process photos showing the dough consistency would be helpful context for troubleshooting when others try to replicate it, since small batch recipes are less forgiving of measurement variations (when you're working with 1/4 cup flour vs 2 cups, a tablespoon off has bigger proportional impact).
The dairy-free option is smart—coconut oil or vegan butter behaves differently than dairy butter (higher melting points, different water content) but small batches are actually easier to adjust for those substitutions since you're not committed to a huge quantity if the first test doesn't work.

Cooking Up Queer Joy with Justin Burke

Icebox cakes, rethinking baking shortcuts, and why potlucks are pillars of the LGBTQIA+ community.
Hi Friends! I hope you are staying warm, and eating well, and taking deep breaths between news cycles. Before we get into this week’s episode I have an exciting bit of news: Not From Concentrate is a featured new podcast on Apple Podcasts!
Catherine Smart ∙ 9 LIKES ∙ 4 RESTACKS
Ariel's avatar
Ariel
I loveeeeeed this cookbook! Can't wait to listen to this one. <3
Maggie Hoffman's avatar
Maggie Hoffman
Looking forward to listening to this while I cook tonight! Loved reading this book.

Strawberry Cheesecake Cookies

pt.1 of my v-day cookie box series!
My favorite thing to bake lately are frosted cookies! They’re so simple to make yet feel so indulgent. And it’s just SO fun making different variations.
Viviane ∙ 16 LIKES
Viviane's avatar
Viviane
This makes around 20-24 cookies, but all depends on the size of each cookie! I used a 1 tbsp cookie scooper but I wasn’t too exact with it so some came out bigger than that.
Chilling isn’t necessary but it can always benefit from it!
I will also have to check them out! I’m always looking for new products to try in my baking, thank you😊
Jackie's avatar
Jackie
Beautiful cookies! Just curious about how many cookies does this make? What size balls should we scoop? In grams or size is fine. Would they benefit from a chill or would it not enhance flavor? Also if you love cookies and flavoring like I do may I recommend you check out amoretti. They have a website. They have over 200 extracts. Most are naturally flavored some alcohol based (water based) some oil based no alcohol so the flavor doesn't bake or freeze off. Also my favorite for cookies is the natural artisan flavorings. They are more affordable. They tell u the conversions for how much flavor per weight of whatever your adding it to. The natural wild strawberry artisan flavoring is what I will use in your cookies. I like to natural artisan flavoring in cookies and oil based extracts in cakes and other bakes. Both work in frosting. Not an Ad I swear I just think you'll love them!

Welcome to From the Center

A living cookbook with reflections informed by Chinese medicine and everyday life
I’ve been asked to write a cookbook more times than I can count. And while I love the idea, what I kept coming back to was something more alive than a bound book.
From The Center ∙ 3 LIKES

Kat Lieu's 108 Asian Cookies

Have a Little Cookbook Chat
The striking cover of Kat Lieu’s most recent book 108 Asian Cookies: Not Too Sweet Treats from a Third-Culture Kitchen is a stunner. It’s the kind of cover that leaps off of the shelf and begs you to flip through the pages, and the recipes within do not disappoint. In this epic book Kat has created a collection of deeply flavorful recipes that highlight…
Yossy Arefi ∙ 16 LIKES ∙ 2 RESTACKS
Allyn Bachran's avatar
Allyn Bachran
This book has now bumped to the top of my to-buy list. Sounds so good (my husband’s lifelong love of haw flakes will be excited to hear of this).
Kat Lieu's avatar
Kat Lieu
Thank you so much for lifting my voice and featuring my recipe, Yossy. I appreciate you so much! <3 With love,
Kat

everything cookies 🍪

this recipe is my roman empire
how was everyone’s weekend? I think I’m finally getting back into my routine here and it feels excellent — long sunset walks, coffee shop work days, chill nights at home and lots of recipe testing and filming.
Emma Kula ∙ 34 LIKES ∙ 2 RESTACKS
carolyn buszynski's avatar
carolyn buszynski
oh okay 100% making these this week
robin's avatar
robin
Would a real egg create same texture as flax egg? I don't have flax. Thanks!!

What To Bake This Year

Pitching you 2026 bakes
Hello, hello, hello and welcome to a brand new year here on Kitchen Projects. It is 2026 and though I can’t see into the future, I am confident there are a LOT of delicious things coming our way (and we’ll be hitting issue #200 pretty soon… WILD)
Nicola Lamb ∙ 228 LIKES ∙ 7 RESTACKS
Kathleen's avatar
Kathleen
I would love some more vegan/plant-based bakes to make for my friends with dietary requirements! Or a deep dive on some of the many cardamom scented bakes from Scandinavia!
Eshun's avatar
Eshun
I’d love a great peanut butter cookie that uses natural style peanut butter (the just peanuts & salt kind). All the good ones use the processed sugary peanut butter which isn’t what I’d ever put on my toast (and hence don’t buy). I’ve tried many times without success so far!

your meal prep plan for today

decrease your mental load this week + prep these easy, nourishing recipes
106 LIKES ∙ 1 RESTACKS
Neural Foundry's avatar
Neural Foundry
Love the fresh and bright angle here. Most winter meal prep guides are just soup after soup, which gets repetitive. The lemon chia pudding actualy flips that script without sacrificing the comfort factor. I've been doing similar with citrus recently and it makes a huge diference in energy during these darker months.
Michelle Schmidt's avatar
Michelle Schmidt
I have been making Spicy Sausage, White Bean, and Kale Soup since you shared it on Insta and it is my go-to soup. For Christmas, I gave my friends Souper Cubes filled (and frozen) with this soup. Also as a hostess gift. The gratitude keeps rolling in as they eat this soup from the freezer at key moments when there is no time to make a meal. This soup brings joy!

Japanese Cheesecake, Semolina Bowl & Cheesy Sweet Potato

This week’s recipe drop #14 — Breakfast, Dessert and dinner ideas you’ll actually love 💌
Hey you 🫶🏼 How’s your week going??
2 LIKES
Han_rie's avatar
Han_rie
💌 I don't often try viral recipes, because most times I don't have the ingredients at home, when I wanna make them 😂. But lately I've tried the Japanese cheesecake and also the bowl with sweet potato, beef, avocado and cottage cheese.

Miso Buttered Toast Cookies: Recipe #26

The cookie that proves my theory that there are truly no limits to what you can make into dessert, as long as you have the right foundations. Miso butter & sourdough toast in a cookie, a revelation!
Do I dare even try and explain how I came up with the idea to combine sourdough toast with a cookie?! How does one explain that they woke up at 2am and thought “i love toast soo much, why isn’t there a buttered toast cookie in every cookie shop when we all collectively
Lungi Mhlanga ∙ 227 LIKES ∙ 18 RESTACKS
Emily Drumm's avatar
Emily Drumm
I made these yesterday with sourdough bread and oh my gosh the texture of this cookie is OUT OF THIS WORLD 🚀.
Michelle May's avatar
Michelle May
I made these at the weekend and they are so delicious. Incredible texture and love the addition of the treacle. So good!

french silk tiramisu

french silk pie 🤝🏼 tiramisu
hello hello and happy friday! here’s what’s new on the blog this week —
Erin Filipowski ∙ 20 LIKES ∙ 2 RESTACKS
Tessi's Kitchen's avatar
Tessi's Kitchen
OH MY GOSH THIS LOOKS INSANE
Neural Foundry's avatar
Neural Foundry
The french silk tiramisu combo is genious! I love how you tackled the raw egg concern by cooking them in the base layer. I tried making a similar hybrid dessert last month with cheesecake and creme brulee but it didnt quite work out. One thing Im curious about is whether the coffee flavor in traditional tiramisu would clash with the chocolate or actually complement it?

Brown Butter Oatmeal Cream Pies

Chewy Brown Butter Oatmeal Cookies with Vanilla Buttercream Filling
Out of everything I bake, oatmeal cream pies are the most consistently requested by my husband. I always run my recipe ideas by him, and when we were talking through Valentine’s recipes this year, he didn’t hesitate.
Ansley Prutsman ∙ 38 LIKES ∙ 5 RESTACKS
THE TROPICAL BAKERY's avatar
THE TROPICAL BAKERY
Looks incredible 🤩😋
Mike's avatar
Mike
Yummy!