Home
>
Topics
>
Cookie Recipes

Top 25 cookie recipes on Substack

Best Cookie Recipes



15 Old-Fashioned Cookies Just Like Grandma Used to Make

Classic cookie recipes filled with familiar flavors, simple ingredients, and plenty of nostalgia.
Click the ❤️ or 🔄 if you’re enjoying this! It helps more people discover the newsletter and spreads the love. Thanks for reading! 💌
Lois Christensen ∙ 5 LIKES ∙ 1 RESTACKS

What I Did and Didn’t Cook During the Nor’easter

Two recipes for squash, three for cookie dough and in the Kitchen Playground: How to Use the Oven Safely.
I’m just outside Boston and we’re in the midst of a pretty uneventful nor’easter, at least so far. I usually like to cook when I’m homebound, especially during a rain or snowstorm but I feel a little iffy about cooking today: my internet went out briefly this morning, and I’m worried about the power going out. I wanted to make something with what I had …
Sally Sampson ∙ 1 LIKES

Meg Alys
Sep 30

Biscuits worth baking

It’s biscuit week in the bake off tent so here is some buttery inspiration worth your baking attention.
Pull up a chair, we’re baking cookies.
Pull up a chair ∙ 13 LIKES ∙ 1 RESTACKS
Robin Hassan's avatar
Robin Hassan
•
Kris Kringle cookies are fab. The mixins (cranberries, white chocolate, nuts) seem too much for the base but they magically just work together!



I’m getting legally married this week!!

And you’re going to love this week’s recipes. I have been BAKING.
Hi guysss!!! (en español abajo)
Alicia ∙ 7 LIKES
Gabriela's avatar
Gabriela
•
Será que, podrías intentar nuevamente a mi correo por favor, ya vacíe muchas cosas, no me llegaban correos ni salían, ahora ya tengo espacio, te lo agradecería muchísimo.
Por cierto sis lo máximo es repostería
;)
Gabriela's avatar
Gabriela
•
Me sale que el documento esta dañado

The Cookie That Never Made It to the Menu

A flavor that was never officially released, but a reminder of the creativity that can happen with a few good recipes.
One of my favorite things I used to do when I made cookies for a living was create what I called Omakase Boxes.
The DTG Kitchen ∙ 1 LIKES

5 High-Protein Recipes to Make in September 🍂

Five easy, sweet high-protein recipes to add to your September lineup.
September recipes might be my favorite because we’re officially getting into cozy season, but I’m not quite ready to go full pumpkin everything yet 😂
Haley Nicole ∙ 4 LIKES

Everyone loves a mashup recipe

When a baked good becomes another baked good, everybody wins.
Let me clue you in on a little secret: People love a mashup recipe. When we reach a rut in recipe brainstorming, we often ask ourselves: Okay, but what if [insert baked good here] was actually [insert another baked good here].
King Arthur Baking and Rossi Anastopoulo ∙ 62 LIKES ∙ 5 RESTACKS
Sophia Real | Real Simple Food's avatar
Sophia Real | Real Simple Food
•
Ok but almond croissant "rugelach" (which is what those cookies look like) is a genius idea!

Healthy Homemade Samoas

A healthier twist on my favorite childhood Girl Scout Cookies, made with a banana + almond flour cookie base, homemade date caramel, coconut + chocolate
Samoas were hands down my favorite Girl Scout cookies growing up, so naturally I had to figure out how to make a healthier version at home. And I’m not gonna lie, these turned out SO good.
courtney | wellness rains

D is for Dunking!

Ever wonder why some Italian cookies are dry? It’s because they are meant to be DUNKED! A recipe for Biscotti da Inzuppo; plus the latest from Penne
Benvenuti! On Thursday, Sept. 24, I’ll be going live here on Substack with my Milano-based friend Laurel Evans to talk about all our favorite fall recipes, dishes, and flavors. We’ll start at 12 p.m. EDT; 9 a.m. PDT; 5 p.m. BST; 6 p.m. CEST. You can join at the appointed time by clicking on
Domenica Marchetti ∙ 47 LIKES ∙ 3 RESTACKS
Gabrielle's avatar
Gabrielle
•
I’d never thought about the difference between a dipping and a dunking cookie!
Honestly, both are favorites. But it all makes sense.
I love those big biscotti da inzuppo with the bits of chocolate. I think they were the first I made from your book. I pretty much always start my day with a big coffee and a few “dry cookies” (hooked on mulino bianco Cioccograno when there’s nothing in the homemade jar). I think today might be a good day to revisit Italian Cookies—we’ve got GF dinner guests and I remember there are one or two that happen to be made with almond flour instead.
Giovanna Solimando's avatar
Giovanna Solimando
•
I never thought of it as dunking versus dipping biscotti :) But now that you mention it, I think the difference may also be about whether you break them and leave them in the bowl to soak up the milk, or just dip them briefly and take them out. I’m trying to think if we’d use a different word for dipping and dunking in Italian, in reference to biscotti. Da inzuppo e .. da bagnare, maybe?

Updated Favorite: Chocolate Chip Cookies

A Tried-and-True Cookie Recipe That’s Still a Family Favorite
Click the ❤️ or 🔄 if you’re enjoying this! It helps more people discover the newsletter and spreads the love. Thanks for reading! 💌
Lois Christensen ∙ 1 LIKES

Martha and Me

That’s all I got this week!
Things are starting to get a little crazy around here! My time is being pulled in every direction. It’s not easy to do all of the things that are asked of you in order to properly promote a book when you are a team of one. Luckily, I do have a little help, both with getting this newsletter out to you each week and with creating videos for social media. …
Susan Spungen ∙ 34 LIKES ∙ 3 RESTACKS
Sue Haggerty's avatar
Sue Haggerty
•
Love everything about the cookie decorating station and am excited to fo it with my granddaughter! 😍
Mariangela's avatar
Mariangela
•
Ok this is all AMAZINGNESS!! You can certainly claim title as new generation doyenne of cookies!
My question is why do you like the smallish looking circular cooling racks?

Recipe Index

I repeat the recipes. Aren't we all supposed to be like that?
I wanted to lose weight so bad. That was 24 years ago. Then I realized that losing weight was not even half of the battle. What happened after losing weight? Found the way to keep it off with simple, repeatable methods. Because I need to live life without thinking too much about the details in the kitchen.
Ilmee Mintz ∙ 8 LIKES ∙ 1 RESTACKS

Batch Better | Week Three

flavored chia pudding, homemade bone broth, marinated meats, & the best black sesame chocolate chip cookies
good morning & happy sunday friends! i’m back for week three of Batch Better - this week is basically my ideal version of weekly meal prep: make a few things once, and you have breakfasts, dinners, snacks and something sweet handled for days (or in this case, weeks).
Olivia Noceda ∙ 35 LIKES ∙ 1 RESTACKS


Violet’s Perfect Gluten-Free Chocolate Chip Cookies

the only chocolate chip cookie recipe I’ll ever need + the food science behind why they taste so good!
A recipe to keep forever.
Violet Russell ∙ 29 LIKES
Taylor's avatar
Taylor
•
Made these day before yesterday and just baked some. Wow wow wow!! I didn’t have heavy cream so I did 2T booked Japanese sweet potato instead. Somehow they still turned out incredible!
Stefanie Sampson's avatar
Stefanie Sampson
•
Got my first batch in the fridge right now!


Chocolate chip freezer cookies

The Cookie Dough I Always Keep in My Freezer 🍪
There are few things I love more than having something homemade in the freezer that I can pull out whenever I need it — and these cookies have officially become one of those things.
Meredith Munoz ∙ 2 LIKES

Coffee + Cookie: Swirled Chocolate-Caramel Shortbread

Soft-set caramel and gooey ganache atop a hazelnut cookie
If you were to ask me what my favorite dessert combo is, I would struggle to answer. I always like to say, ‘It depends on the season: berries and cream in the summer! Pecans in November! My Brooklyn blackout cake for my birthday!’ But for my husband, it’s clear: any time and any place, the same formula reigns supreme: praliné (hazelnuts and caramel) and…
Paris Starn ∙ 46 LIKES ∙ 6 RESTACKS

Apparently, Brown Butter Is Cringe Now

Unfortunately, it’s still fucking delicious.
Seems like the internet is tired of brown butter now. I’ve seen a few posts lately from online pastry creators who are absolutely over the brown butter trend and have declared they’ll never put it in a cookie again. It had a good run. We browned it. We put it in cookies. We put it in cakes. We put it in buttercream, Rice Krispie treats, brownies, blondi…
Brown Butter Sundays ∙ 5 LIKES

What to Cook this October

8 Easy Recipes to Love this Month!
This is one of my favorite months. We have several birthdays this time of year plus Halloween - our family loves a holiday that includes candy & creepy things.
The Short Order Cook ∙ 2 LIKES

Chewy Ginger, Apricot & Pepita Cookies

Equal parts sugar & spice.
For the longest time, I really didn’t enjoy ginger in sweet contexts whatsoever. I found its spiciness unpleasantly sharp and overpowering. Then a few years ago, I grew up.
Bella ∙ 9 LIKES

The Fall 2026 Cookbook Preview

175+ books and a trend report
This post is way too long for your email! Please click through to read it in a browser or on the app.
Jenna Helwig ∙ 161 LIKES ∙ 22 RESTACKS
Marie's avatar
Marie
•
Everybody shut up, it’s preview day at Cookbookery Collective!
At this point, it should be a national holiday
Maggie Hoffman's avatar
Maggie Hoffman
•
An epic list! (and an epic day for BOTH our newsletters.) I'm so excited about this fall!