Home
>
Topics
>
Cookie Recipes

Top 25 cookie recipes on Substack

Best Cookie Recipes


easygayoven
December 19, 2025

The 7 Recipes in This Year's Cookie Box

A 2025 Cookie Box Recap
This year’s cookie box bonanza wrapped on Wednesday evening and since then, we’ve been in distribution mode. You might think spending almost three days of your life on seven different cookie recipes to fill 17 cookie boxes is the hardest part about this holiday tradition. It’s not. The hardest part is hand-delivering to and coordinating pick-ups with th…
Eric King ∙ 53 LIKES
Patty Terhune's avatar
Patty Terhune
Hahahaha I laughed out loud at the intro. The hamster wheel rarely stops. Happy closure season, EGO! 🍪
Abena Anim-Somuah's avatar
Abena Anim-Somuah
SO FIRE!!!!

ZoëBakes Newsletter
December 11, 2025

Cookie Swap Prep: A Few Favorite Recipes

Some of my favorite holiday cookie recipes.
It’s peak holiday cookie season! Today’s a little warmup for my Holiday Cookie Exchange Extravaganza newsletter for “Extras” subscribers. (It’s coming Saturday so upgrade your subscription now to get it in your inbox!)
Zoë François ∙ 37 LIKES ∙ 2 RESTACKS
CHRISTINE PAULL's avatar
CHRISTINE PAULL
Thank you for the recipes, Zoe!
Stephanie Hansen's avatar
Stephanie Hansen
The cookies in @foodandwine spectacular

Fwd: from a friend
December 18, 2025

Holiday baking, but make it slightly unhinged

The unglamorous truth behind my cookie boxes (and the 9 recipes I’d actually recommend)
It was on Christmas Eve, three years ago, in the middle of making my Yule Log, a notoriously high-maintenance dessert, that I realized I should probably be medicated.
Emily Schuman ∙ 145 LIKES ∙ 2 RESTACKS
Sudeshna Dillard's avatar
Sudeshna Dillard
It’s a work of art, Emily. You’re an artist. And yes, I agree with some comments here that say it’s incredibly glamorous! You’re a badass! 😊
Alison Schramm's avatar
Alison Schramm
I bake cookies this time of year also and give little bags out to everyone from mail person to waste management to speech therapists. Mine aren’t the prettiest 😂 (following recipes and rules isn’t always my jam!) but there’s something so sweet about giving homemade cookies. “Here, I made this for you” ❤️ It’s also a beautiful connection to my (Italian-American) grandma who made 18 different types of cookies every year with her sisters. Happy holidays!

Everything I made for my Not Cookie Boxes

I swapped the cookie baking marathon for recipes that I could make over a few days, and I absolutely loved it.
Before we jump into hosting extravaganza 2026 (I am SO excited to share with you what I have planned), I have a few things I need to wrap up from 2025.
Becca Cousins ∙ 6 LIKES
Trish Hipolito's avatar
Trish Hipolito
These are beautiful! What a lovely gift to receive. Im saving this for the next holiday season.

slip away

new cookie recipes and eating a whole potato
Is it still okay to say happy new year? What’s the grace period on that— a week? The first half of the month? The first time you talk to someone again, so long as it’s in January? No one really knows. Anyway, I hope everyone had a good one, and a good holiday if you celebrate. Jeff got a bad cold the …
divine beastmode ∙ 2 LIKES
Neural Foundry's avatar
Neural Foundry
This is brilliant! The miso and grainy mustard combo for brussels spouts sounds like a gamechanger. I've been stuck in the balsamic reduction routine for years, but the umami depth from miso probly balances that slight bitterness way better. Gotta try this with the Christmas leftovers sittin in my fridge.

A viral dumpling bake, a great sweater, and the joy of The Magic Flute

Plus, my three favorite cookie recipes
We’re piled into the car, following Route 22 toward home. Outside, the sky has settled into soft bands of pale blue, pink, and grey. My mind is still back at the Metropolitan Opera’s performance of t…
Abbey Nova ∙ 35 LIKES
jenny andrews's avatar
jenny andrews
abbey the fruit stand has an incorrect link i think? it just goes to a chairish decorative bowls page. i need to know because i love it!
Christina Power's avatar
Christina Power
I've been curious about the dumpling bake but hesitant to try it without a recommendation from a "real" person. Lol. I might have to give it a go.

Strawberry Cheesecake Cookies

pt.1 of my v-day cookie box series!
My favorite thing to bake lately are frosted cookies! They’re so simple to make yet feel so indulgent. And it’s just SO fun making different variations.
Viviane ∙ 7 LIKES
Viviane's avatar
Viviane
This makes around 20-24 cookies, but all depends on the size of each cookie! I used a 1 tbsp cookie scooper but I wasn’t too exact with it so some came out bigger than that.
Chilling isn’t necessary but it can always benefit from it!
I will also have to check them out! I’m always looking for new products to try in my baking, thank you😊
Jackie's avatar
Jackie
Beautiful cookies! Just curious about how many cookies does this make? What size balls should we scoop? In grams or size is fine. Would they benefit from a chill or would it not enhance flavor? Also if you love cookies and flavoring like I do may I recommend you check out amoretti. They have a website. They have over 200 extracts. Most are naturally flavored some alcohol based (water based) some oil based no alcohol so the flavor doesn't bake or freeze off. Also my favorite for cookies is the natural artisan flavorings. They are more affordable. They tell u the conversions for how much flavor per weight of whatever your adding it to. The natural wild strawberry artisan flavoring is what I will use in your cookies. I like to natural artisan flavoring in cookies and oil based extracts in cakes and other bakes. Both work in frosting. Not an Ad I swear I just think you'll love them!

before I hit publish

everything that happens before a recipe hits your inbox
hey hi hello,
Kassie Mendieta ∙ 34 LIKES
Vee's avatar
Vee
The method behind the madness revealed! 🙌
gabrianna's avatar
gabrianna
If you ever need someone to cross-test a recipe, I’d be down to volunteer 👀

Kat Lieu's 108 Asian Cookies

Have a Little Cookbook Chat
The striking cover of Kat Lieu’s most recent book 108 Asian Cookies: Not Too Sweet Treats from a Third-Culture Kitchen is a stunner. It’s the kind of cover that leaps off of the shelf and begs you to flip through the pages, and the recipes within do not disappoint. In this epic book Kat has created a collection of deeply flavorful recipes that highlight…
Yossy Arefi ∙ 13 LIKES ∙ 2 RESTACKS
Allyn Bachran's avatar
Allyn Bachran
This book has now bumped to the top of my to-buy list. Sounds so good (my husband’s lifelong love of haw flakes will be excited to hear of this).
Kat Lieu's avatar
Kat Lieu
Thank you so much for lifting my voice and featuring my recipe, Yossy. I appreciate you so much! <3 With love,
Kat


Irish Soda Bread Muffin Scones with Raspberry Jam & Brown Cheese

A repost from Food52
My goal for 2026 is to become better at planning out my recipes, which means developing them a month or so in advance, giving myself and my (new) recipe tester ample time to brainstorm and test. However, to do that while still posting content and recipes, I have to slot in pre-existing recipes!
Nea Arentzen ∙ 22 LIKES ∙ 2 RESTACKS
P Sol's avatar
P Sol
Thanks for the recipe! How long would these keep for at room temp and can they be frozen?
taylor's avatar
taylor
i made these multiple times last spring when you first published the recipe. they are so good and come together really quickly!

Lemon Pistachio Almond Shortbread

A cozy little biscuit that also happens to be gluten-free. Not even on purpose. Just because it tastes good.
(Clicking the like button above will mean confectioner’s sugar will fall from the sky over New Jersey instead of snow. It also will help the algorithm and my pursuit of greatness and world cookie domination. [evil laugh] Thank you.)
Marissa Rothkopf ∙ 261 LIKES ∙ 33 RESTACKS
j dinerman's avatar
j dinerman
You mention a “link at the bottom” if you want to help. I couldn’t find it, and I’m always eager to share what you have to say.
I appreciate your recipes and comments. Always. -had
Susan B's avatar
Susan B
Thanks for this yummy looking recipe. Your cookie book is amazing and I gifted a couple too!

David Lebovitz Newsletter
December 12, 2025

Mokonuts Multigrain Chocolate Chip Cookies

From Mokonuts bakery in Paris
David Lebovitz ∙ 378 LIKES ∙ 13 RESTACKS
Jordan Battani's avatar
Jordan Battani
These look fabulous. And the recipe is timely…I’ve had a shopping/inventory management malfunction recently, and picked up a bag of sunflower seeds and one of pepitas pretty much everytime I was at the market this Fall. Just last night I was looking at all the bags and thinking - How much Killer Granola does everyone I know need….? Probably some, because it’s a Bread Garden recipe, duh…..AND now they’ll get fabulous cookies too! I’m gonna be pop-u-lar…..
Mardi Michels's avatar
Mardi Michels
Never eaten there but on my list! Will make these cookies over the holidays! thanks for sharing the recipe!


Well Made Weekly Roundup

a peek at this week’s bakes, a few things I loved, and a reminder for your heart as we head into a new week.
Hi friends —
Kiley Heard ∙ 6 LIKES
Chentzu's avatar
Chentzu
Sending prayers your way for a safe and successful move. Congratulations on your new house!

A Cookie Like A Kiss, Baci di Dama For A Sweet January

The Recipe Is Courtesy of My Friend from Life's A Feast, Jamie Schler
Well, my New Year did NOT get off to roaring start. A week ago I started feeling weird, not sick sick but wrong. I didn’t have a fever but was miserable with a stuffy nose, cough etc. I tested for Covid, Flu A, FluB, every time was negative. Since I didn’t feel well enough to go out, always a warning sign, I called the doctor. It turns out I am a victim…
KathyGori ∙ 11 LIKES ∙ 4 RESTACKS
Jamie Schler's avatar
Jamie Schler
Kathy!! I’m so glad you’re back on your feet and feeling better! And baking! Funny, my son has been ordering boxes of baci di dama from a fancy bakery in Milan and I keep telling him how easy they are to make…I’ve not made them since I bought the hotel but I’ve been wanting to. I guess it’s about time. I’m happy you love them. Thank you for the beautiful shoutout, my friend 😘😘😘




On The Rocks
December 14, 2025

What I'm Making This Holiday Season

cookie party details!! plus, cranberry & cardamom crinkle cookies, holiday chip towers, and 3 homemade tea blends
last weekend i hosted my 1st annual Cookie (& tea) Party!!! there were 20 girls and over 250 cookies taking over my dining room. we rotated between eating cookies and chips… and drank hot tea to help recover from said cookies and chips. a beautiful ecosystem.
Olivia Noceda ∙ 53 LIKES ∙ 1 RESTACKS
Deborah Roccanova's avatar
Deborah Roccanova
WOW.....fabulous cookie and tea party. Beautiful and delicious Olivia! Merry Christmas!
Wilderness Lou's avatar
Wilderness Lou
Did the viral dried sugar coated cranberry recipe work from this TikTok?
I’ve tried so many TikTok recipes that have failed epically 🤣

Hidden Gems from the "Recipe Graveyard"

These recipes never disappoint and you probably didn't even know about them
January has not been off to a good start. I won’t get into details at this point, but there has been an accident with one of my dogs, and it’s gonna be a long road to recovery. Probably an accident that would have been preventable, and clearly the “woulda shoulda coulda” is currently killing me (and eating up all my mental health).
Daniela Weiner ∙ 18 LIKES ∙ 1 RESTACKS
Valerie's avatar
Valerie
Take care of your dog and yourself. We’ll bake our way through your catalog while we wait for more of your fabulous recipes.
Neural Foundry's avatar
Neural Foundry
Super thoughtful way to keep showing up for readers while also giving yourself permission to step back when life demands it. The recipe graveyard concept is smart, sometimes the best content is already sitting there waiting to be rediscovered. Hope the pup's recovery goes smoothly and that mental health burden eases up soonish.


Gluten Free Magic Cookies

Because we all could use a little magic now and then
Gluten Free Magic Cookies
Daniela Weiner ∙ 24 LIKES ∙ 2 RESTACKS
Neural Foundry's avatar
Neural Foundry
Love the peanut butter hack for binding. Gluten-free baking is all about finding those little tricks that mimick gluten's structure, and using PB as both binder and flavor boost is smart. I've been seeing the same AI scraping issue across food blogs, it's brutal watching someone repost a recipe they clearly never tested. The spread problem with sweetend coconut makes total sense too since higher sugar content affects moisture balance.

Friends in the Kitchen

Celebrating 10 years of recipes made easy and being with friends in the kitchen.
Hello Welcome to the first Recipe Crumbs Newsletter of 2026
Jacqueline Bellefontaine ∙ 4 LIKES
Mary B's avatar
Mary B
The photos are fantastic, regardless of their age, and always inspire me to try the delicious recipes you share! What fun to visit friends' kitchens and bake away the morning/day together. Looking forward to everything this baking year has to bring, and thanks as always for sharing your love and enthusiasm for the baking arts, as well as your recipes. 😁
Neural Foundry's avatar
Neural Foundry
Love how this captures the collaborative joy of recipe sharing. The fact that Eva's macaron recipe came from someone who's a "Star Baker" is exactly the kind of peer-to-peer learning that makes cooking less intimidating. I tried making macarons once years ago and it was a disaster, but having that kind of detailed insight from someone who's nailed thetechnique would have probably saved me. Congrats on the 10 year milestone!

everything cookies 🍪

this recipe is my roman empire
how was everyone’s weekend? I think I’m finally getting back into my routine here and it feels excellent — long sunset walks, coffee shop work days, chill nights at home and lots of recipe testing and filming.
Emma Kula ∙ 16 LIKES
carolyn buszynski's avatar
carolyn buszynski
oh okay 100% making these this week
Jane Ford's avatar
Jane Ford
Cannot WAIT to make these!!!🥰